Plaza Grill Restaurant

It was very easy to make reservations. our server was fantastic. decor and atmosphere were great. they had a little trouble matching up the year and bottle of wine. The plates were very large and the food was delicious. We came from jacksonville however if we go back to the keys we will be here again.

Perhaps the best food and cocktails in Marathon. Service was exceptional, and the atmosphere was perfect for fine dining. This place is small, so I would recommend reservations for dinner. The steak was cooked perfectly, and the cocktails were well made and worth every penny. Bartender will do mocktails at a modest price, and they are just as good as the real thing. Give this place a try and support a local business.

Okay so when we walked in the way they said the food is good the service sucks he was right the service sucked $25 corkage fee limited wine menu I will not come back here again

Excellent food & service.

Had the coconut crusted snapper, it was cooked perfectly.

Some of the best food and service in Mararhon. The atmosphere is more like a fancy restaurant on the mainland, not Keysee.

We had an amazing dinner tonight. Got there for happy hour drinks. Red snapper with risotto was delicious and Neven our server was awesome.

We read all of the reviews and thought we booked a really good place for a nice dinner. Not so much. The salad was completely drenched in dressing, the ravioli appetizer tasted frozen and then we ordered the filet well done. We explained we wanted no pink at all. They brought the steak and it was very pink. We sent it back and it was still not cooked enough. We sent it back and said we didnt want to try anymore. When we got the bill the steak was on it even though we didnt eat it. Twe brought this to our waitresses attention and the manager came over. They did finally take everything off of the bill other...

Atmosphere was great, wish I could say that about the food. Personally I got the 12oz NY strip steak which came with broccoli and steak fries. I didn’t think for the 42 dollars, I should of gotten French fries. My steak was on the edge of being over cooked. I asked for medium rare and it came out basically medium with minimal pink. The blue cheese on top of the steak was great but was a bit much. My grandparents were with me when I went. My grandmother got the filet mignon with instant cold mash potatoes that were bigger then her steak and piled high on her plate. My grandfather got the small plate Mussels & Clam...

(Translated by Google) The manager who clears the tables with a glass of wine, imposes a discretionary 20% tip on us because we speak French. I had to return my filet mignon because it was not cooked properly. The poor waitress gave us very good service despite everything. To avoid! (Original) La gérante qui défait les tables avec une coupe de vin, nous impose un pourboire de 20% discrétionnaire car nous parlons français. J’ai dû retourner mon filet mignon car la cuisson n’était pas adéquate. La pauvre serveuse nous a donné malgré tout un très bon service. À éviter!

Absolutely amazing dinner! From the service to the appetizer to the drinks and dinner! I will definitely be back. Our server was Elizabeth, she was super sweet and knew how to explain/recommend the dishes. I drank the Billionaire Margarita (delicious) and my husband ordered a wine bottle. I had the lobster tails with mashed potatoes and broccolini it was to die for. I will definitely come back and I enjoyed my dinner very much!

Drinks were great , lots of very neat options. Food was delicious. The Pesto Risoto was a must have. Nevin, our server, was super! Must go-to place while in Marathon!!

Overpriced, Bad sevice, Don't order the fish it comes with a pool of sickly sauce for it to swim in.

This is the place where we have celebrated anniversaries and birthdays for the last 15 years. There is NOTHING that compares! (And Bobby rocks!

Good food pleasant decor

Great meal and great service. They will see us again.

Very nicely decorated, the steak was cooked perfectly but lacked flavor especially for a steak costing $60! The bar crowd was a bit rowdy for a restaurant of this supposed caliber! It has the potential to be a great restaurant if someone steps in before the local drinkers take it over!

Meh. Came because after twenty years of coming to the Keys, and now living here, we had never been. Menu selection was very limited and service was not amazing even though we were the only non-bar customers. Very small place, but not small in a romantic candle-lit dinner sort of way. Food was good, especially if you like knowing exactly what it's going to taste like before you get it, but way too traditional/same as I've had at any good Italian place.

Food was average but okay. However, the most uncomfortable chairs! Lastly, Wagu meat advertised was not real wagu meat sorry your supplier lies to you. As a suggestion open the blinds for sunsets, back charge your supplier for meat and teach your wait staff to be more attentive for the $$&

Restaurant quite nice. Service was great! Quality of food was just ok. Not many choices of sides. OVER PRICED!! For a $46 steak we got fries on the side. My wife had $48 fillet with a side of cold instant potatoes. Myself I got $30 mussels, clams fra-Diavolo. Clams were gritty & two different sizes of pasta which made some of the pasta mushy. No breads or salads. Looks like they had a good bar crowd. They should work on the kitchen crew.

Terrible service. The kitchen failed to put my son's order in. As a kind gesture of service recovery the owner took $3 off his $17 fettuccini. Nice ... $3 off a $100 order. Never return.

S/o to Michael for his upbeat and contagiously great vibes. Killer steak and desserts. Drinks that really pack a punch

We were on vacation and decided on having dinner at this exceptional restaurant. As soon as we walked in the door, the host was so friendly and helpful in suggesting a martini and food and I am so glad that I asked him. He was 100% right! The waitress was very nice and prompt. This has been the best dining experience ever! Fresh and Delicious! Thank you